seaweedfs

Chris Lu f52a3c87ce lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics (#8811 ) * lifecycle worker: add NoncurrentVersionExpiration support Add version-aware scanning to the rule-based execution path. When the walker encounters a .versions directory, processVersionsDirectory(): - Lists all version entries (v_<versionId>) - Sorts by version timestamp (newest first) - Walks non-current versions with ShouldExpireNoncurrentVersion() which handles both NoncurrentDays and NewerNoncurrentVersions - Extracts successor time from version IDs (both old/new format) - Skips delete markers in noncurrent version counting - Falls back to entry Mtime when version ID timestamp is unavailable Helper functions: - sortVersionsByTimestamp: insertion sort by version ID timestamp - getEntryVersionTimestamp: extracts timestamp with Mtime fallback * lifecycle worker: address review feedback for noncurrent versions - Use sentinel errLimitReached in versions directory handler - Set NoncurrentIndex on ObjectInfo for proper NewerNoncurrentVersions evaluation * lifecycle worker: fail closed on XML parse error, guard zero Mtime - Fail closed when lifecycle XML exists but fails to parse, instead of falling back to TTL which could apply broader rules - Guard Mtime > 0 before using time.Unix(mtime, 0) to avoid mapping unset Mtime to 1970, which would misorder versions and cause premature expiration * lifecycle worker: count delete markers toward NoncurrentIndex Noncurrent delete markers should count toward the NewerNoncurrentVersions retention threshold so data versions get the correct position index. Previously, skipping delete markers without incrementing the index could retain too many versions after delete/recreate cycles. * lifecycle worker: fix version ordering, error propagation, and fail-closed scope 1. Use full version ID comparison (CompareVersionIds) for sorting .versions entries, not just decoded timestamps. Two versions with the same timestamp prefix but different random suffixes were previously misordered, potentially treating the newest version as noncurrent and deleting it. 2. Propagate .versions listing failures to the caller instead of swallowing them with (nil, 0). Transient filer errors on a .versions directory now surface in the job result. 3. Narrow the fail-closed path to only malformed lifecycle XML (errMalformedLifecycleXML). Transient filer LookupEntry errors now fall back to TTL with a warning, matching the original intent of "fail closed on bad config, not on network blips." * lifecycle worker: only skip .uploads at bucket root * lifecycle worker: sort.Slice, mixed-format test, XML presence tracking - Replace manual insertion sort with sort.Slice in sortVersionsByVersionId - Add TestCompareVersionIdsMixedFormats covering old/new format ordering - Distinguish "no lifecycle XML" (nil) from "XML present but no effective rules" (non-nil empty slice) so buckets with all-disabled rules don't incorrectly fall back to filer.conf TTL expiration * lifecycle worker: guard nil Attributes, use TrimSuffix in test - Guard entry.Attributes != nil before accessing GetFileSize() and Mtime in both listExpiredObjectsByRules and processVersionsDirectory - Use strings.TrimPrefix/TrimSuffix in TestVersionsDirectoryNaming to match the production code pattern * lifecycle worker: skip TTL scan when XML present, fix test assertions - When lifecycle XML is present but has no effective rules, skip object scanning entirely instead of falling back to TTL path - Test sort output against concrete expected names instead of re-using the same comparator as the sort itself * lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics Rewrite cleanupDeleteMarkers() to only remove delete markers that are the sole remaining version of an object. Previously, delete markers were removed unconditionally which could resurface older versions in versioned buckets. New algorithm: 1. Walk bucket tree looking for .versions directories 2. Check ExtLatestVersionIsDeleteMarker from directory metadata 3. Count versions in the .versions directory 4. Only remove if count == 1 (delete marker is sole version) 5. Require an ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker=true rule (when lifecycle XML rules are present) 6. Remove the empty .versions directory after cleanup This phase runs after NoncurrentVersionExpiration so version counts are accurate. * lifecycle worker: respect prefix filter in ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules Previously hasDeleteMarkerRule was a bucket-wide boolean that ignored rule prefixes. A prefix-scoped rule like "logs/" would incorrectly clean up delete markers in all paths. Add matchesDeleteMarkerRule() that checks if a matching enabled ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rule exists for the specific object key, respecting the rule's prefix filter. Falls back to legacy behavior (allow cleanup) when no lifecycle XML rules are provided. * lifecycle worker: only skip .uploads at bucket root Check dir == bucketPath before skipping directories named .uploads. Previously a user-created directory like data/.uploads/ at any depth would be incorrectly skipped during lifecycle scanning. * lifecycle worker: fix delete marker cleanup with XML-present empty rules 1. matchesDeleteMarkerRule now uses nil check (not len==0) for legacy fallback. A non-nil empty slice means lifecycle XML was present but had no ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules, so cleanup is blocked. Previously, an empty slice triggered the legacy true path. 2. Use per-directory removedHere flag instead of cumulative cleaned counter when deciding to remove .versions directories. Previously, after the first successful cleanup anywhere in the bucket, every subsequent .versions directory would be removed even if its own delete marker was not actually deleted. * lifecycle worker: use full filter matching for delete marker rules matchesDeleteMarkerRule now uses s3lifecycle.MatchesFilter (exported) instead of prefix-only matching. This ensures tag and size filters on ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules are respected, preventing broader deletions than the configured policy intends. Add TestMatchesDeleteMarkerRule covering: nil rules (legacy), empty rules (XML present), prefix match/mismatch, disabled rules, rules without the flag, and tag-filtered rules against tagless markers. --------- Co-authored-by: Copilot <copilot@github.com>	18 hours ago
..
worker	lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics (#8811)	18 hours ago

lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics (#8811 )

* lifecycle worker: add NoncurrentVersionExpiration support

Add version-aware scanning to the rule-based execution path. When the
walker encounters a .versions directory, processVersionsDirectory():
- Lists all version entries (v_<versionId>)
- Sorts by version timestamp (newest first)
- Walks non-current versions with ShouldExpireNoncurrentVersion()
  which handles both NoncurrentDays and NewerNoncurrentVersions
- Extracts successor time from version IDs (both old/new format)
- Skips delete markers in noncurrent version counting
- Falls back to entry Mtime when version ID timestamp is unavailable

Helper functions:
- sortVersionsByTimestamp: insertion sort by version ID timestamp
- getEntryVersionTimestamp: extracts timestamp with Mtime fallback

* lifecycle worker: address review feedback for noncurrent versions

- Use sentinel errLimitReached in versions directory handler
- Set NoncurrentIndex on ObjectInfo for proper NewerNoncurrentVersions
  evaluation

* lifecycle worker: fail closed on XML parse error, guard zero Mtime

- Fail closed when lifecycle XML exists but fails to parse, instead
  of falling back to TTL which could apply broader rules
- Guard Mtime > 0 before using time.Unix(mtime, 0) to avoid mapping
  unset Mtime to 1970, which would misorder versions and cause
  premature expiration

* lifecycle worker: count delete markers toward NoncurrentIndex

Noncurrent delete markers should count toward the
NewerNoncurrentVersions retention threshold so data versions
get the correct position index. Previously, skipping delete
markers without incrementing the index could retain too many
versions after delete/recreate cycles.

* lifecycle worker: fix version ordering, error propagation, and fail-closed scope

1. Use full version ID comparison (CompareVersionIds) for sorting
   .versions entries, not just decoded timestamps. Two versions with
   the same timestamp prefix but different random suffixes were
   previously misordered, potentially treating the newest version as
   noncurrent and deleting it.

2. Propagate .versions listing failures to the caller instead of
   swallowing them with (nil, 0). Transient filer errors on a
   .versions directory now surface in the job result.

3. Narrow the fail-closed path to only malformed lifecycle XML
   (errMalformedLifecycleXML). Transient filer LookupEntry errors
   now fall back to TTL with a warning, matching the original intent
   of "fail closed on bad config, not on network blips."

* lifecycle worker: only skip .uploads at bucket root

* lifecycle worker: sort.Slice, mixed-format test, XML presence tracking

- Replace manual insertion sort with sort.Slice in sortVersionsByVersionId
- Add TestCompareVersionIdsMixedFormats covering old/new format ordering
- Distinguish "no lifecycle XML" (nil) from "XML present but no effective
  rules" (non-nil empty slice) so buckets with all-disabled rules don't
  incorrectly fall back to filer.conf TTL expiration

* lifecycle worker: guard nil Attributes, use TrimSuffix in test

- Guard entry.Attributes != nil before accessing GetFileSize() and
  Mtime in both listExpiredObjectsByRules and processVersionsDirectory
- Use strings.TrimPrefix/TrimSuffix in TestVersionsDirectoryNaming
  to match the production code pattern

* lifecycle worker: skip TTL scan when XML present, fix test assertions

- When lifecycle XML is present but has no effective rules, skip
  object scanning entirely instead of falling back to TTL path
- Test sort output against concrete expected names instead of
  re-using the same comparator as the sort itself

* lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics

Rewrite cleanupDeleteMarkers() to only remove delete markers that are
the sole remaining version of an object. Previously, delete markers
were removed unconditionally which could resurface older versions in
versioned buckets.

New algorithm:
1. Walk bucket tree looking for .versions directories
2. Check ExtLatestVersionIsDeleteMarker from directory metadata
3. Count versions in the .versions directory
4. Only remove if count == 1 (delete marker is sole version)
5. Require an ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker=true rule (when lifecycle
   XML rules are present)
6. Remove the empty .versions directory after cleanup

This phase runs after NoncurrentVersionExpiration so version counts
are accurate.

* lifecycle worker: respect prefix filter in ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules

Previously hasDeleteMarkerRule was a bucket-wide boolean that ignored
rule prefixes. A prefix-scoped rule like "logs/" would incorrectly
clean up delete markers in all paths.

Add matchesDeleteMarkerRule() that checks if a matching enabled
ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rule exists for the specific object key,
respecting the rule's prefix filter. Falls back to legacy behavior
(allow cleanup) when no lifecycle XML rules are provided.

* lifecycle worker: only skip .uploads at bucket root

Check dir == bucketPath before skipping directories named .uploads.
Previously a user-created directory like data/.uploads/ at any depth
would be incorrectly skipped during lifecycle scanning.

* lifecycle worker: fix delete marker cleanup with XML-present empty rules

1. matchesDeleteMarkerRule now uses nil check (not len==0) for legacy
   fallback. A non-nil empty slice means lifecycle XML was present but
   had no ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules, so cleanup is blocked.
   Previously, an empty slice triggered the legacy true path.

2. Use per-directory removedHere flag instead of cumulative cleaned
   counter when deciding to remove .versions directories. Previously,
   after the first successful cleanup anywhere in the bucket, every
   subsequent .versions directory would be removed even if its own
   delete marker was not actually deleted.

* lifecycle worker: use full filter matching for delete marker rules

matchesDeleteMarkerRule now uses s3lifecycle.MatchesFilter (exported)
instead of prefix-only matching. This ensures tag and size filters
on ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker rules are respected, preventing broader
deletions than the configured policy intends.

Add TestMatchesDeleteMarkerRule covering: nil rules (legacy), empty
rules (XML present), prefix match/mismatch, disabled rules, rules
without the flag, and tag-filtered rules against tagless markers.

---------

Co-authored-by: Copilot <copilot@github.com>

18 hours ago

worker

lifecycle worker: fix ExpiredObjectDeleteMarker to match AWS semantics (#8811)

18 hours ago