package protocol import ( "encoding/binary" "testing" ) // This file demonstrates what FIELD-LEVEL testing would look like // Currently these tests are NOT run automatically because they require // complex parsing logic for each API. // TestJoinGroupResponseStructure shows what we SHOULD test but currently don't func TestJoinGroupResponseStructure(t *testing.T) { t.Skip("This is a demonstration test - shows what we SHOULD check") // Hypothetical: build a JoinGroup response // response := buildJoinGroupResponseV6(correlationID, generationID, protocolType, ...) // What we SHOULD verify: t.Log("Field-level checks we should perform:") t.Log(" 1. Error code (int16) - always present") t.Log(" 2. Generation ID (int32) - always present") t.Log(" 3. Protocol type (string/compact string) - nullable in some versions") t.Log(" 4. Protocol name (string/compact string) - always present") t.Log(" 5. Leader (string/compact string) - always present") t.Log(" 6. Member ID (string/compact string) - always present") t.Log(" 7. Members array - NON-NULLABLE, can be empty but must exist") t.Log(" ^-- THIS is where the current bug is!") // Example of what parsing would look like: // offset := 0 // errorCode := binary.BigEndian.Uint16(response[offset:]) // offset += 2 // generationID := binary.BigEndian.Uint32(response[offset:]) // offset += 4 // ... parse protocol type ... // ... parse protocol name ... // ... parse leader ... // ... parse member ID ... // membersLength := parseCompactArray(response[offset:]) // if membersLength < 0 { // t.Error("Members array is null, but it should be non-nullable!") // } } // TestProduceResponseStructure shows another example func TestProduceResponseStructure(t *testing.T) { t.Skip("This is a demonstration test - shows what we SHOULD check") t.Log("Produce response v7 structure:") t.Log(" 1. Topics array - must not be null") t.Log(" - Topic name (string)") t.Log(" - Partitions array - must not be null") t.Log(" - Partition ID (int32)") t.Log(" - Error code (int16)") t.Log(" - Base offset (int64)") t.Log(" - Log append time (int64)") t.Log(" - Log start offset (int64)") t.Log(" 2. Throttle time (int32) - v1+") } // CompareWithReferenceImplementation shows ideal testing approach func TestCompareWithReferenceImplementation(t *testing.T) { t.Skip("This would require a reference Kafka broker or client library") // Ideal approach: t.Log("1. Generate test data") t.Log("2. Build response with our Gateway") t.Log("3. Build response with kafka-go or Sarama library") t.Log("4. Compare byte-by-byte") t.Log("5. If different, highlight which fields differ") // This would catch: // - Wrong field order // - Wrong field encoding // - Missing fields // - Null vs empty distinctions } // CurrentTestingApproach documents what we actually do func TestCurrentTestingApproach(t *testing.T) { t.Log("Current testing strategy (as of Oct 2025):") t.Log("") t.Log("LEVEL 1: Static Code Analysis") t.Log(" Tool: check_responses.sh") t.Log(" Checks: Correlation ID patterns") t.Log(" Coverage: Good for known issues") t.Log("") t.Log("LEVEL 2: Protocol Format Tests") t.Log(" Tool: TestFlexibleResponseHeaderFormat") t.Log(" Checks: Flexible vs non-flexible classification") t.Log(" Coverage: Header format only") t.Log("") t.Log("LEVEL 3: Integration Testing") t.Log(" Tool: Schema Registry, kafka-go, Sarama, Java client") t.Log(" Checks: Real client compatibility") t.Log(" Coverage: Complete but requires manual debugging") t.Log("") t.Log("MISSING: Field-level response body validation") t.Log(" This is why JoinGroup issue wasn't caught by unit tests") } // parseCompactArray is a helper that would be needed for field-level testing func parseCompactArray(data []byte) int { // Compact array encoding: varint length (length+1 for non-null, 0 for null) length := int(data[0]) if length == 0 { return -1 // null } return length - 1 // actual length } // Example of a REAL field-level test we could write func TestMetadataResponseHasBrokers(t *testing.T) { t.Skip("Example of what a real field-level test would look like") // Build a minimal metadata response response := make([]byte, 0, 256) // Brokers array (non-nullable) brokerCount := uint32(1) response = append(response, byte(brokerCount>>24), byte(brokerCount>>16), byte(brokerCount>>8), byte(brokerCount)) // Broker 1 response = append(response, 0, 0, 0, 1) // node_id = 1 // ... more fields ... // Parse it back offset := 0 parsedCount := binary.BigEndian.Uint32(response[offset : offset+4]) // Verify if parsedCount == 0 { t.Error("Metadata response has 0 brokers - should have at least 1") } t.Logf("✓ Metadata response correctly has %d broker(s)", parsedCount) }