Go's EcVolume.Sync() flushes both the .ecj journal and the .ecx index
to disk. The Rust version only flushed .ecj, leaving in-place deletion
marks in .ecx unpersisted until close(). This could cause data
inconsistency if the server crashes after marking a needle deleted in
.ecx but before close().
Go's r.FormValue() cannot read multipart text fields after
r.MultipartReader() consumes the body, so ts/ttl sent as multipart
form fields only work with the Rust volume server. Skip this test
when VOLUME_SERVER_IMPL != "rust" to fix CI failure.
Go checks extraSize > 256*256-2 and calls glog.Fatalf to prevent
corrupt super block headers. Rust was silently truncating via u16 cast,
which would write an incorrect extra_size field.
Go calls ev.ecxFile.Sync() before closing to ensure in-place deletion
marks are flushed to disk. Without this, deletion marks written via
MarkNeedleDeleted could be lost on crash.
Go sets ev.Version = needle.Version(volumeInfo.Version) from the .vif
file. Rust was always using Version::current() (V3), which would produce
wrong needle actual size calculations for volumes created with V1 or V2.
Go's r.ParseForm() returns HTTP 400 with "form parse error: ..." when
the query string is malformed. Rust was silently falling back to empty
query params via unwrap_or_default().
Go sets ETag at L235 AFTER the If-Modified-Since and If-None-Match
304 return paths, so Go's 304 responses do not include the ETag header.
The Rust code was incorrectly including ETag in both 304 response paths.
Go maps both "" and "hdd" to HardDriveType (empty string). The
Rust enum variant is HardDrive, not Hdd. The test referenced a
nonexistent Hdd variant causing compilation failure.
Go's Shutdown() calls vs.store.Close() which closes all volumes
and flushes file handles. The Rust server was relying on process
exit for cleanup, which could leave data unflushed.
Go unconditionally sets isHeartbeating: true in the VolumeServer
struct literal. Rust was starting with false when masters are
configured, causing /healthz to return 503 until the first
heartbeat succeeds.
Go's jwt.ParseWithClaims validates the nbf claim when present,
rejecting tokens whose nbf is in the future. The Rust jsonwebtoken
crate defaults validate_nbf to false, so tokens with future nbf
were incorrectly accepted.
Go's tryHandleChunkedFile only falls back from URL filename to
manifest name. Rust had an extra fallback to needle.name that
Go does not perform, which could produce different
Content-Disposition filenames for chunk manifests.
Go sets ETag on the response writer (via SetEtag) before the
If-Modified-Since and If-None-Match conditional checks, so both
304 response paths include the ETag header. The Rust implementation
was only adding ETag to 200 responses.
Go's json.ToJson produces records with unquoted keys like
{score:12} not {"score":12}. This is a custom format used
internally by SeaweedFS for query results.
Go's State.Update compares the incoming version with the stored
version and returns "version mismatch" error if they differ. This
provides optimistic concurrency control. The Rust implementation
was accepting any version unconditionally.
Go's ReadTTL calls fitTtlCount which normalizes to the coarsest unit
that fits: 7 days = 1 week, so "7d" becomes {Count:1, Unit:Week}
which displays as "1w". Both Go and Rust normalize identically.
Go's ScrubEcVolume switches on mode: INDEX calls v.ScrubIndex()
(ecx integrity only), LOCAL calls v.ScrubLocal(), FULL calls
vs.store.ScrubEcVolume(). Rust was ignoring the mode and always
running verify_ec_shards. Now INDEX mode checks ecx index integrity
(sorted overlap detection + file size validation) without shard I/O,
while LOCAL/FULL modes run the existing shard verification.
Go's ProcessRangeRequest returns nil (empty body, 200 OK) when
parsed ranges are empty or combined range size exceeds total content
size. The Rust buffered path incorrectly returned the full file data
for both cases. The streaming path already handled this correctly.
Go's doCheckAndFixVolumeData reads AppendAtNs from both live entries
(verifyNeedleIntegrity) and deleted tombstones (verifyDeletedNeedleIntegrity).
Rust was skipping deleted entries, which could result in a stale
last_append_at_ns if the last index entry is a deletion.
Go's hasFreeDiskLocation returns true immediately when MaxVolumeCount
is 0, treating it as unlimited. Rust was computing effective_free as
<= 0 for max==0, rejecting the location. This could fail volume
creation during early startup before the first heartbeat adjusts max.
Go checks reqNeedle.HasName() before setting ret.Name. Rust always set
the name from the filename variable, which could return the fid portion
of the path as the name for raw PUT requests without a filename.
Go checks both Accept-Encoding contains "gzip" AND IsGzippedContent
(data starts with 0x1f 0x8b) before setting Content-Encoding: gzip.
Rust only checked Accept-Encoding, which could incorrectly declare
gzip encoding for non-gzip compressed data.
Go uses max(preallocate, estimatedCompactSize) for the free space check.
Rust was only using the estimated volume size, which could start a
compaction that fails mid-way if preallocate exceeds the volume size.
Was counting EC volumes instead of EC shards, which underestimates EC
space usage. One EC volume with 14 shards uses ~1.4 volume slots, not 1.
Now uses Go's formula: ((max - volumes) * DataShardsCount - ecShardCount) / DataShardsCount.
Go reads the gRPC CA file only from config.GetString("grpc.ca"), i.e.
the [grpc] section. The [grpc.volume] section only provides cert and
key. Rust was also reading ca from [grpc.volume] which would silently
override the [grpc].ca value when both were present.
Go calls v.SetDefault("jwt.signing.expires_after_seconds", 10) and
v.SetDefault("jwt.signing.read.expires_after_seconds", 60). Rust
defaulted to 0 for both, which meant tokens would never expire when
security.toml has a signing key but omits expires_after_seconds.
Go checks `volumeSize < super_block.SuperBlockSize` (strict less-than),
but Rust used `<=`. This meant Rust would fail to expire a volume that
is exactly SUPER_BLOCK_SIZE bytes.
Go's NeedleMap.Delete unconditionally writes a tombstone entry to the
idx file and updates metrics, even if the needle doesn't exist or is
already deleted. This is important for replication where every delete
operation must produce an idx write. The Rust version was skipping the
tombstone write for non-existent or already-deleted needles.
Go's ScanVolumeFileFrom visits ALL needles including deleted ones.
Skipping deleted entries during incremental copy would cause tombstones
to not be propagated, making deleted files reappear on the receiving side.
Go's encoding/json always includes empty strings and zero values in
the upload response. The Rust version was using skip_serializing_if
to omit them, causing JSON structure differences.
Go always sets Content-MD5 in the response regardless of whether the
request included it. The Rust version was conditionally including it
only when the request provided Content-MD5.
Go's ReadTTL calls fitTtlCount which converts to seconds and normalizes
to the coarsest unit that fits in a byte count (e.g. 120m->2h, 7d->1w,
24h->1d). The Rust version was preserving the original unit, producing
different binary encodings on disk and in heartbeat messages.
Go's SetState unconditionally applies the state without any version
mismatch check. The Rust version had an extra optimistic concurrency
check that would reject valid requests from Go clients that don't
track versions.
Match Go's volume_grpc_client_to_master.go behavior:
1. Only trigger leader redirect when the leader address differs from the
current master (prevents unnecessary reconnect loops when master confirms
its own address).
2. Process duplicated_uuids before leader redirect check, matching Go's
ordering where duplicate UUID detection takes priority.
* improve large file sync throughput for remote.cache and filer.sync
Three main throughput improvements:
1. Adaptive chunk sizing for remote.cache: targets ~32 chunks per file
instead of always starting at 5MB. A 500MB file now uses ~16MB chunks
(32 chunks) instead of 5MB chunks (100 chunks), reducing per-chunk
overhead (volume assign, gRPC call, needle write) by 3x.
2. Configurable concurrency at every layer:
- remote.cache chunk concurrency: -chunkConcurrency flag (default 8)
- remote.cache S3 download concurrency: -downloadConcurrency flag
(default raised from 1 to 5 per chunk)
- filer.sync chunk concurrency: -chunkConcurrency flag (default 32)
3. S3 multipart download concurrency raised from 1 to 5: the S3 manager
downloader was using Concurrency=1, serializing all part downloads
within each chunk. This alone can 5x per-chunk download speed.
The concurrency values flow through the gRPC request chain:
shell command → CacheRemoteObjectToLocalClusterRequest →
FetchAndWriteNeedleRequest → S3 downloader
Zero values in the request mean "use server defaults", maintaining
full backward compatibility with existing callers.
Ref #8481
* fix: use full maxMB for chunk size cap and remove loop guard
Address review feedback:
- Use full maxMB instead of maxMB/2 for maxChunkSize to avoid
unnecessarily limiting chunk size for very large files.
- Remove chunkSize < maxChunkSize guard from the safety loop so it
can always grow past maxChunkSize when needed to stay under 1000
chunks (e.g., extremely large files with small maxMB).
* address review feedback: help text, validation, naming, docs
- Fix help text for -chunkConcurrency and -downloadConcurrency flags
to say "0 = server default" instead of advertising specific numeric
defaults that could drift from the server implementation.
- Validate chunkConcurrency and downloadConcurrency are within int32
range before narrowing, returning a user-facing error if out of range.
- Rename ReadRemoteErr to readRemoteErr to follow Go naming conventions.
- Add doc comment to SetChunkConcurrency noting it must be called
during initialization before replication goroutines start.
- Replace doubling loop in chunk size safety check with direct
ceil(remoteSize/1000) computation to guarantee the 1000-chunk cap.
* address Copilot review: clamp concurrency, fix chunk count, clarify proto docs
- Use ceiling division for chunk count check to avoid overcounting
when file size is an exact multiple of chunk size.
- Clamp chunkConcurrency (max 1024) and downloadConcurrency (max 1024
at filer, max 64 at volume server) to prevent excessive goroutines.
- Always use ReadFileWithConcurrency when the client supports it,
falling back to the implementation's default when value is 0.
- Clarify proto comments that download_concurrency only applies when
the remote storage client supports it (currently S3).
- Include specific server defaults in help text (e.g., "0 = server
default 8") so users see the actual values in -h output.
* fix data race on executionErr and use %w for error wrapping
- Protect concurrent writes to executionErr in remote.cache worker
goroutines with a sync.Mutex to eliminate the data race.
- Use %w instead of %v in volume_grpc_remote.go error formatting
to preserve the error chain for errors.Is/errors.As callers.
TTL::read: Go's ReadTTL preserves the original unit (7d stays 7d,
not 1w) and errors on count > 255. The previous normalization change
was incorrect — Go only normalizes internally via fitTtlCount, not
during string parsing.
DiskStatus: Go uses encoding/json on protobuf structs, which reads
the json struct tags (snake_case: percent_free, percent_used,
disk_type), not the protobuf JSON names (camelCase). Revert to
snake_case to match Go's actual output.
Chris Lu
Chris Lu
Copilot